| Roosters | Raiders | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Player | Rating | Player | Rating | |
| Fullback | Sam Perrett | 6 | Bronx Goodwin | 6 |
| Winger | Amos Roberts | 6 | Colin Best | 6 |
| Winger | Shaun Kenny-Dowall | 7 | Brett Kelly | 5 |
| Centre | Sia Soliola | 7 | Adrian Purtell | 5 |
| Centre | Mitchell Aubusson | 7 | Joel Monaghan | 7 |
| Five-eighth | Braith Anasta | 7 | Terry Campese | 6 |
| Halfback | Mitchell Pearce | 6 | Todd Carney | 6 |
| Prop | Mark O'Meley | 7 | Scott Logan | 5 |
| Prop | Frank Paul-Nuuausala | 6 | Dane Tilse | 6 |
| Hooker | Riley Brown | 6 | Lincoln Withers | 5 |
| Second-row | Nate Myles | 7 | Marshall Chalk | 5 |
| Second-row | Willie Mason | 8 | Nigel Plum | 5 |
| Lock | Craig Fitzgibbon | 8 | Alan Tongue | 6 |
| Interchange | Lopini Paea | 6 | Troy Thompson | 5 |
| Interchange | Setaimata Sa | 7 | Joe Picker | 5 |
| Interchange | Anthony Tupou | 7 | Josh Miller | 6 |
| Interchange | James Aubusson | 6 | Trevor Thurling | 5 |
Judge: Will Swanton, The Sun-Herald
| Bulldogs | Panthers | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Player | Rating | Player | Rating | |
| Fullback | Brent Crisp | 5 | Rhys Wesser | 7 |
| Winger | Hazem El Masri | 5 | Geoff Daniela | 6 |
| Winger | Matt Utai | 6 | Michael Gordon | 7 |
| Centre | Tim Winitana | 5 | Michael Jennings | 6 |
| Centre | Cameron Phelps | 5 | Brad Tighe | 7 |
| Five-eighth | Lee Te Maari | 5 | Maurice Blair | 7 |
| Halfback | Daniel Holdsworth | 5 | Luke Lewis | 8 |
| Prop | Jarrad Hickey | 6 | Tony Puletua | 6 |
| Prop | Chris Armit | 5 | Petero Civoniceva | 8 |
| Hooker | Corey Hughes | 5 | Luke Priddis | 6 |
| Second-row | Nick Kouparitsas | 5 | Trent Waterhouse | 7 |
| Second-row | Andrew Ryan | 6 | Joseph Paulo | 7 |
| Lock | Rene Maitua | 5 | Nathan Smith | 7 |
| Interchange | Justin Tsoulos | 5 | Frank Pritchard | 5 |
| Interchange | Michael Sullivan | 5 | Paul Aiton | 6 |
| Interchange | Lorenzo Ma'afu | 5 | Frank Puletua | 5 |
| Interchange | Gary Warburton | 5 | Matthew Bell | 5 |
Judge: Adrian Proszenko, The Sun-Herald
| Cowboys | Sharks | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Player | Rating | Player | Rating | |
| Fullback | Ashley Graham | 7 | Brett Kearney | 7 |
| Winger | Mark Henry | 7 | Luke Covell | 6 |
| Winger | John Williams | 7 | Misi Taulapapa | 7 |
| Centre | Ben Harris | 6 | Ben Pomeroy | 7 |
| Centre | Ben Farrer | 6 | David Simmons | 6 |
| Five-eighth | Travis Burns | 5 | Brett Seymour | 7 |
| Halfback | Johnathan Thurston | 6 | Brett Kimmorley | 8 |
| Prop | Ray Cashmere | 7 | Danny Nutley | 7 |
| Prop | Carl Webb | 8 | Kade Snowden | 6 |
| Hooker | Aaron Payne | 6 | Isaac De Gois | 7 |
| Second-row | Steve Southern | 7 | Fraser Anderson | 7 |
| Second-row | Luke O'Donnell | 7 | Dustin Cooper | 6 |
| Lock | Justin Smith | 6 | Greg Bird | 8 |
| Interchange | Daniel Abraham | 6 | Paul Gallen | 8 |
| Interchange | Anthony Watts | 6 | Luke Douglas | 8 |
| Interchange | Dayne Weston | 5 | Terence Seu Seu | 5 |
| Interchange | Ben Vaeau | 5 | Bryan Norrie | 5 |
Judge: Greg Prichard, Sydney Moring Herald
| Broncos | Sea Eagles | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Player | Rating | Player | Rating | |
| Fullback | Karmichael Hunt | 7 | Brett Stewart | 7 |
| Winger | Denan Kemp | 6 | Michael Robertson | 6 |
| Winger | Reece Robinson | 6 | David Williams | 6 |
| Centre | Darius Boyd | 6 | Steve Bell | 6 |
| Centre | Joel Moon | 6 | Steve Matai | 7 |
| Five-eighth | David Stagg | 7 | Jamie Lyon | 7 |
| Halfback | Peter Wallace | 6 | Matt Orford | 8 |
| Prop | Ben Hannant | 7 | Glenn Hall | 6 |
| Prop | Joel Clinton | 6 | Josh Perry | 7 |
| Hooker | Michael Ennis | 8 | Matt Ballin | 6 |
| Second-row | Sam Thaiday | 7 | Steve Menzies | 7 |
| Second-row | Ashton Sims | 6 | Glenn Stewart | 7 |
| Lock | Greg Eastwood | 7 | Luke Williamson | 7 |
| Interchange | PJ Marsh | 5 | Brent Kite | 8 |
| Interchange | Nick Kenny | 5 | Adam Cuthbertson | 7 |
| Interchange | David Taylor | 5 | Mark Bryant | 6 |
| Interchange | Derrick Watkins | 5 | Heath L'Estrange | 6 |
Judge: Brad Walter, The Sydney Morning Herald
| Eels | Dragons | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Player | Rating | Player | Rating | |
| Fullback | Luke Burt | 8 | Brett Morris | 7 |
| Winger | Joel Reddy | 7 | Jason Nightingale | 7 |
| Winger | Eric Grothe | 7 | Chase Stanley | 8 |
| Centre | Ben Smith | 6 | Mark Gasnier | 7 |
| Centre | Jarryd Hayne | 7 | Matt Cooper | 7 |
| Five-eighth | Feleti Mateo | 7 | Jamie Soward | 7 |
| Halfback | Brett Finch | 6 | Ben Hornby | 6 |
| Prop | Nathan Cayless | 7 | Justin Poore | 6 |
| Prop | Fuifui Moimoi | 7 | Jason Ryles | 8 |
| Hooker | Matthew Keating | 6 | Dean Young | 6 |
| Second-row | Nathan Hindmarsh | 8 | Beau Scott | 6 |
| Second-row | Daniel Wagon | 6 | Lagi Setu | 6 |
| Lock | Chad Robinson | 6 | Ben Creagh | 7 |
| Interchange | Mark Riddell | 5 | Kirk Reynoldson | 6 |
| Interchange | Brendan Oake | 5 | Simon Woolford | 4 |
| Interchange | Weller Hauraki | 5 | Stuart Webb | 5 |
| Interchange | Junior Paulo | 6 | Dan Hunt | 6 |
Judge: Glenn Jackson, Sydney Morning Herald
| Storm | Broncos | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Player | Rating | Player | Rating | |
| Fullback | Billy Slater | 7 | Kurt Gidley | 7 |
| Winger | Steve Turner | 6 | James McManus | 7 |
| Winger | Anthony Quinn | 6 | Cooper Vuna | 7 |
| Centre | Will Chambers | 6 | Wes Naiqama | 7 |
| Centre | Israel Folau | 7 | Keith Lulia | 6 |
| Five-eighth | Greg Inglis | 6 | Chris Bailey | 6 |
| Halfback | Cooper Cronk | 7 | Jarrod Mullen | 8 |
| Prop | Antonio Kaufusi | 5 | Danny Wicks | 6 |
| Prop | Brett White | 6 | Ben Cross | 6 |
| Hooker | Cam Smith | 7 | Danny Buderus | 8 |
| Second-row | Sam Tagataese | 6 | Chris Houston | 7 |
| Second-row | Ryan Hoffman | 6 | Cory Paterson | 7 |
| Lock | Dallas Johnson | 7 | Zeb Taia | 7 |
| Interchange | Matt Geyer | 5 | Matt Hilder | 7 |
| Interchange | Adam Blair | 6 | Jesse Royal | 7 |
| Interchange | Jeremy Smith | 6 | Daniel Tolar | 7 |
| Interchange | Michael Crocker | 7 | Cameron Ciraldo | 6 |
Judge: Brett Keeble, The Newcastle Herald and Stathi Paxinos, The Age
